The IT Girl

The Operating System · Opinion

Are Women Actually Less Confident About AI, or Have Men Simply Made Themselves the Default Experts Again?

Apparently, all it takes to become the office AI expert is to be a man who has opened ChatGPT.

Draft. Not yet edited or fact-checked.

I have a small theory about men and artificial intelligence.

Apparently, all it takes to become the office AI expert is to be a man who has opened ChatGPT.

I say this as someone who has lost count of the number of times a man has explained AI to me, entirely unaware that I spend my spare time vibecoding for fun. I have listened politely. I have nodded. On occasion, I have wondered whether I should start charging for the privilege of attending these unsolicited masterclasses.

There is something quite remarkable about the confidence with which some men will explain a subject to a woman before establishing whether she knows anything about it. AI has simply given this particular personality trait a new area of expertise.

It got me thinking. Are women actually less confident about using AI, or have men simply made themselves the default experts again?

Confidence is a funny thing

There is research suggesting that the confidence gap is real. A 2023 meta-analysis examined 115 studies across 22 countries and found that men rated their technological abilities higher than women did. The difference was relatively small and had narrowed over time, but it was there.

The researchers also found significant variation between countries. Which is interesting, because it rather complicates the idea that men are simply born with an innate understanding of technology. Apparently, confidence can be shaped by the environment you grow up and work in. Who knew?

A separate study published in Economics Letters in 2024 found that 50% of men had used generative AI, compared with 37% of women. The researchers looked at why the gap existed. Self-assessed knowledge of AI emerged as the most important factor.

Read that again. How much of the adoption gap comes down to whether people believe they know what they’re doing?

I find that particularly interesting in an industry where confidence has a habit of being mistaken for competence. We all know the colleague who can turn a fairly ordinary observation into a 20-minute presentation, preferably with a diagram. And we all know that being the first person to speak in a meeting does not necessarily mean having the best idea.

Yet somehow, the confidence itself becomes part of the evidence.

A little caution never hurt anyone

Women are often encouraged to be more confident in technology. Apply for the job even if you don’t meet every requirement. Speak up in the meeting. Put yourself forward. Learn the tools. Don’t let imposter syndrome hold you back.

Fine. But perhaps we should also ask why confidence is the quality we keep asking women to improve.

A 2026 study published in PNAS Nexus surveyed around 3,000 people in Canada and the United States. It found that women consistently perceived AI as riskier than men did. The researchers linked this to differences in general risk orientation and women’s greater exposure to AI-related risks. Women were also more likely to question whether AI would deliver positive economic outcomes.

You could call that scepticism. You could call it caution. You could even call it having a functioning sense of self-preservation.

The point is that women are being encouraged to adopt a technology whose risks are still being worked out, while their concerns are sometimes treated as a confidence problem.

I would quite like to see the same enthusiasm for asking difficult questions that we see for announcing AI strategies.

The boys have discovered a new toy

There is another reason to be cautious about the rush to embrace AI. Some of its most immediate applications have been deeply unpleasant.

Generative AI has made it easier to create fake intimate images of women and distribute them without consent. A 2024 study involving more than 16,000 respondents across ten countries examined non-consensual synthetic intimate imagery. It found that 2.2% of respondents had experienced victimisation, while 1.8% reported perpetration behaviours. Men reported higher levels of both.

A separate study published in 2025 examined image-based sexual abuse across ten countries. Men were 1.59 times more likely than women to report perpetrating at least one form of image-based sexual abuse.

There is something grimly predictable about a technology being celebrated for democratising creativity while also making it easier to manufacture sexual abuse. The tools have become more accessible. The consequences have not become any less real.

And before someone tells me that technology itself is neutral, I’m aware. A kitchen knife can also be used to make a sandwich. That doesn’t mean we should ignore what people are doing with it.

Women have good reason to be interested in who gets access to these tools, how they are used and who is left dealing with the fallout.

Who gets to define progress?

Then there is the environmental question.

The International Energy Agency reported that electricity consumption by data centres increased by 17% in 2025. Electricity consumption from AI-focused data centres grew by 50%. Those numbers are worth remembering the next time an app introduces an AI feature that nobody asked for.

The industry is in a race to make AI part of practically everything. Sometimes the use case is genuinely useful. Sometimes it feels as though someone has put a chatbot in a product simply because the board asked where the AI strategy was.

Meanwhile, the infrastructure behind these products requires electricity, water and physical resources. The environmental impact deserves the same scrutiny as the productivity claims.

There is also a wider gender context. OECD data from 2024 found that 73% of women were concerned about climate change, compared with 63% of men. This does not tell us whether women are more concerned about AI’s environmental footprint specifically. It does show a difference in how women and men report thinking about environmental risk.

I wonder what AI development would look like if the people asking about its energy consumption, social consequences and potential for abuse had as much influence as the people selling its productivity benefits.

It might be a slightly less exciting pitch deck. It could also be a more responsible industry.

Perhaps the confidence problem is somewhere else

The conversation about women and AI keeps returning to the same familiar advice. Learn the tools. Build your skills. Be confident. Don’t get left behind.

Women should absolutely have access to AI education, technical roles and the opportunity to build these products. There is no question about that.

But I am less interested in another initiative teaching women how to feel more confident while the industry carries on without them.

I want to know who is deciding what gets built. Who is setting the rules. Who is questioning the assumptions in the models. Who is considering the people whose images, jobs, data and livelihoods may be affected.

And I want to know why a man can spend an afternoon prompting ChatGPT and come away with the confidence of a newly appointed CTO, while a woman who has been working with technology for years is still expected to demonstrate that she belongs in the conversation.

Perhaps women are less confident about AI. Perhaps some are more cautious. Perhaps some simply have a longer list of questions before they’re prepared to call something progress.

I don’t think the industry should be in such a hurry to correct that.